Pelkey’s Tavern

Pelkey’s Tavern has been part of Catskills history since the 1890s—and now it’s ready for its next chapter. With indoor and outdoor spaces, a huge yard with a stage, and a rustic barn full of possibilities, this is a chance to build something special in a part of Sullivan County that’s beautiful and an increasingly popular destination.⁠

There’s a huge back yard with room for yard games, picnic benches and a stage for live music. The stage is backed by a large rustic barn with space for storage galore—or an exciting new vision? The fully equipped and spacious commercial kitchen is well maintained and ready to work.

The entire building was recently renovated with new electric, LED lighting, plumbing, insulation, sheetrock, siding, gutters, and a NIK security camera system. Sitting at the bar—or standing behind it!—feels great, and Pelkey’s is outfitted for karaoke and open mic nights.

The large yard + barn combo—ready for reinvention, backyard hangs, or the best kind of late-night magic.⁠

Upstairs is a large 4-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment with high ceilings and great light. The kitchen and laundry rooms are waiting to be finished, though they are fully functional. The apartment would be ideal for an owner-operator or could be an income generating rental. There is so much potential in this location. Just follow the signs from Roscoe to Pelkey’s.

Sale is handled by Megan Brenn-White of the Upstate Curious Team at Compass Realty.